Jasper Morris Inside Burgundy uses a combination of the following two scales to help distinguish a truly successful wine.

 

The 100 Point Scale

Most international publications have taken to this scale. It is much more useful in Bordeaux or for other regions where a producer offers a single wine, but less well in Burgundy or wherever a producer has a wide range of wines which tend broadly to follow a hierarchical pattern – in our case generic Bourgogne, village, lieu-dit, premier cru, grand cru.

There will be occasions when a Bourgogne Rouge stands out as a more successful wine than the same producer’s village wine but this doesn’t happen often. So we need some way to flag up wines which are really fine examples of their category. So step forward… The Five Star Scale

 

The Five Star Scale

An outstanding wine in its category. This accolade will be given very rarely, certainly to less than 10% of wines tasted across the year. A generic Bourgogne might deserve this reward if it merits 89 or 90 points whereas a Puligny-Montrachet Les Pucelles would need 96 for the same result.

An excellent wine in its category and given the ‘unicorn’ status of the fifth star, any producer receiving 4 stars for a wine should be extremely proud of their achievement.

A wine that meets or exceeds expectations: the producer has done very well in this vintage. These wines are recommended for purchase if they fall within your style and pricing brackets.

Two stars may seem ungenerous, but nonetheless this wine fulfils what the appellation or vineyard should be able to offer. While the little bit extra may not be readily evident, this is still a well-made wine.

A little bit disappointing compared to expectations. We hope that there will not be too many wines in this category, given that most wines tasted come from producers pre-selected for their quality.

Some wines may not gain a star of any sort though these will normally be suffering from a specific fault.

Recent Reports

  • A Tale of 3 Burgundian Châteaux
    A Tale of 3 Burgundian Châteaux
    There is a talking point behind this: the authorities have drawn the attention of the proprietors of those Châteaux which bear the name of their...
    Read More
  • Red Burgfest: The 2016 Vintage
    Red Burgfest: The 2016 Vintage
    The usual team of tasters – 10 of us – met at the Hameau de Barboron in September 2019 to spend four days tasting blind...
    Read More
  • 1993 Revisited
    1993 Revisited
    The following 1993 Burgundies were drunk over an excellent dinner at London’s Chez Bruce restaurant. The wines were not served blind. The purpose was to...
    Read More
  • A Tour Around the Hill of Corton
    A Tour Around the Hill of Corton
    In July 2019 I spent the best part of the week in and around the Hill of Corton, visiting many of the key players. Separate...
    Read More
  • Domaine de la Romanée-Conti: Corton Vertical 2009-2017
    Domaine de la Romanée-Conti: Corton Vertical 2009-2017
    It was not so much that Aubert de Villaine was looking out for some Corton vineyards, but he had been looking for a challenge outside...
    Read More
  • Domaine Faiveley: Corton Clos des Cortons-Faiveley Vertical
    Domaine Faiveley: Corton Clos des Cortons-Faiveley Vertical
    The story behind the naming of Clos des Cortons Faiveley is a good one. Faiveley bought what was specified in the paperwork as Clos des...
    Read More
  • A Pinot Lunch at Berry Bros & Rudd
    A Pinot Lunch at Berry Bros & Rudd
    I returned to No 3 St James’s Street in May to host a lunch showing some of my favourite pinots from around the world. The...
    Read More
  • Domaine Direct
    Domaine Direct
    One of London’s leading Burgundy importers is chary of the annual En Primeur frenzy. Instead, once the wines have been bottled, they put on a...
    Read More
  • Dinner at Berry Bros & Rudd: taking a look at some 2005s
    Dinner at Berry Bros & Rudd: taking a look at some 2005s
    As you may know, I think of 2005 as probably the best red Burgundy vintage of my working lifetime. I am also more of a...
    Read More

Register with JMIB to learn more about Burgundy and its wine...

  • Receive details by email of the latest news to come from inside and outside Burgundy
  • Interact with other JMIB members by commenting on articles
  • Feel something is missing? You will be able to give feedback on the JMIB website
  • Manage your account so you are always kept up to date from JMIB
  • Registration is FREE and you can cancel your JMIB account whenever you wish.
  • Your Details

  • Minimum length of 8 characters.

Close
Register with Inside Burgundy

Register with Inside Burgundy and select a membership plan that works for you

Click here to register