Jasper Morris Inside Burgundy uses a combination of the following two scales to help distinguish a truly successful wine.

 

The 100 Point Scale

Most international publications have taken to this scale. It is much more useful in Bordeaux or for other regions where a producer offers a single wine, but less well in Burgundy or wherever a producer has a wide range of wines which tend broadly to follow a hierarchical pattern – in our case generic Bourgogne, village, lieu-dit, premier cru, grand cru.

There will be occasions when a Bourgogne Rouge stands out as a more successful wine than the same producer’s village wine but this doesn’t happen often. So we need some way to flag up wines which are really fine examples of their category. So step forward… The Five Star Scale

 

The Five Star Scale

An outstanding wine in its category. This accolade will be given very rarely, certainly to less than 10% of wines tasted across the year. A generic Bourgogne might deserve this reward if it merits 89 or 90 points whereas a Puligny-Montrachet Les Pucelles would need 96 for the same result.

An excellent wine in its category and given the ‘unicorn’ status of the fifth star, any producer receiving 4 stars for a wine should be extremely proud of their achievement.

A wine that meets or exceeds expectations: the producer has done very well in this vintage. These wines are recommended for purchase if they fall within your style and pricing brackets.

Two stars may seem ungenerous, but nonetheless this wine fulfils what the appellation or vineyard should be able to offer. While the little bit extra may not be readily evident, this is still a well-made wine.

A little bit disappointing compared to expectations. We hope that there will not be too many wines in this category, given that most wines tasted come from producers pre-selected for their quality.

Some wines may not gain a star of any sort though these will normally be suffering from a specific fault.

Recent Reports

  • Delving Deep in the Bouchard Père et Fils Cellars
    Delving Deep in the Bouchard Père et Fils Cellars
    Every so often the team at Bouchard Père et Fils pull out some old bottles from their stash to see how they are developing, and...
    Read More
  • Jasper on Zoom: Grand Cru Burgundy: Chambertin Clos de Bèze
    Jasper on Zoom: Grand Cru Burgundy: Chambertin Clos de Bèze
    The second in our grand cru series features Chambertin Clos-de-Bèze, sibling or perhaps consort of Chambertin itself. This wine was so brilliantly described by Evelyn...
    Read More
  • Jasper on Zoom: Beaujolais: Moulin-à-Vent
    Jasper on Zoom: Beaujolais: Moulin-à-Vent
    The most powerful of the Beaujolais crus and the most age-worthy is surely Moulin-à-Vent, a wine which can seem positively Burgundian as it ages. It...
    Read More
  • Jasper on Zoom: Grand Cru Burgundy: Romanée-St-Vivant
    Jasper on Zoom: Grand Cru Burgundy: Romanée-St-Vivant
    The first in our series looking at individual grand crus in detail, will focus on Romanée-St-Vivant, the quintessential vineyard capable of displaying the hallmark of...
    Read More
  • Jasper on Zoom: Jasper’s Top 6 Côte Chalonnaise Vignerons
    Jasper on Zoom: Jasper’s Top 6 Côte Chalonnaise Vignerons
    Question: Where to go in Burgundy for fine quality at fair prices? Answer: to the very best producers of the Côte Chalonnaise. I have chosen...
    Read More
  • Marsannay
    Marsannay
    Between the return of the vignerons from their summer holidays and the start of the vintage, I visited several domaines in Marsannay and Fixin to...
    Read More
  • Fixin
    Fixin
    Between the return of the vignerons from their summer holidays and the start of the vintage, I visited several domaines in Marsannay and Fixin to...
    Read More
  • Jasper on Zoom: Chambolle-Musigny Combe d’Orveau
    Jasper on Zoom: Chambolle-Musigny Combe d’Orveau
    This unusual vineyard in Chambolle-Musigny should not be overlooked. It is the only lieu-dit in all of Burgundy which has four classifications from generic to grand cru...
    Read More
  • Auxey-Duresses
    Auxey-Duresses
    Now is the time to start investigating what might have been considered as backwater villages, but where global warming is bringing the ability to ripen...
    Read More
Log in to Inside Burgundy
Forgotten Password?
Don't have an account? Subscribe here!